If you are at the point of losing your home to foreclosure, selling your home may be able to help you limit the damage to your credit, preserve equity that you have built up, avoid additional costs, and allow you to be in control of the sale timeline.
This article will compare foreclosure and selling your home, exploring how you may be able to protect your financial future by selling before foreclosure, reducing the stress and uncertainty associated with a lengthy public legal process, and salvage your VA loan entitlement.
Quick Answer: Selling your home before foreclosure can protect your credit score, save the equity you have in your home, and allow you to avoid the extra costs, legal fees, embarrassment, and penalties associated with a foreclosure.
What Is Foreclosure and How Does It Work?
When you take out a mortgage to buy your home, the lender uses your home as collateral in exchange for lending you the money to buy the house. In essence, you agree that you will hold up your end of the bargain by making on-time payments according to the loan terms.
If you fail to meet those terms and miss mortgage payments, your lender can take action to recoup the outstanding amount, plus any additional expenses. This legal process is called foreclosure.
Fortunately, federal and lender loss-mitigation options enacted after the 2008 financial crisis positively impacted the foreclosure process, creating a more constructive relationship between the lender and the homeowner. These options include assistance to homeowners struggling to make mortgage payments. Protections vary by state and loan type.
It is important to know that foreclosure is not something that either party wants to happen, and many lenders will try very hard to avoid it through a series of steps, such as forbearance, repayment plans, refinancing, or helping you sell your home.
If you have a VA-backed loan and are having trouble making payments, the VA may help you avoid foreclosure. If your VA loan becomes for more than 60 days, the VA may assign a loan specialist to help you.
Defining Foreclosure and Mortgage Default
If efforts to prevent foreclosure fail, and foreclosure is unavoidable, know that it is not a quick process. Your lender is required to go through a series of steps before your home is sold at auction.
Step 1: Missed Payments and Key Timelines (30 to 120 Days)
Missing mortgage payments can result in a series of outcomes, depending on how late you are.
- If your payment is late, you will get a notice from your lender stating that you are late and will likely be assessed a late fee.
- If you are more than 30 days late, you are considered delinquent and lenders may report it to the credit bureaus.
- A second missed payment (60 days past due) has an even more negative impact on your credit score.
- If you are more than 90 days past due, you will get a letter of default from your lender, letting you know they intend to foreclose within 30 days. Your lender may also take pre-foreclosure actions by filing with the court and placing your name in a public notice listing borrowers facing foreclosure.
- In many cases, lenders are required to wait until a loan is at least 120 days late, before starting foreclosure action. The state your home is located in may have different time periods and requirements before moving on to this next step, so make sure you check with your lender.
Note: This may be your last chance to work out arrangements with your lender to avoid losing your house.
Step 2: Legal Filing (Judicial vs. Nonjudicial)
This is when foreclosure is officially initiated, and documents have been filed to start the process. You have not lost your home yet, but your options are shrinking.
Foreclosure typically follows two paths: judicial or nonjudicial. Foreclosure procedures differ by state; some states primarily use judicial foreclosure, while others allow nonjudicial foreclosure because it is less expensive and less time-consuming.
- Judicial Foreclosure: The lender files a lawsuit against you saying that they have the right to foreclose. However, you also have the right to defend yourself. This process can take up to several years to play out in court.
- Nonjudicial Foreclosure: In this process, your lender starts the procedure outside court, and it is basically a notification process recorded in the county where you defaulted. The notice states what you can do to come to agreeable terms with your lender, and how long you have. This could take days or several months.
Step 3: Notice of Sale and Public Auction
A separate Notice of Sale occurs with most judicial foreclosures and some nonjudicial foreclosures. A notice of sale is a legal document telling you that your lender plans to auction off your home. The notice lists the date, time, and place of the upcoming public sale.
Step 3: Auction
The auction starts with a minimum bid of what is owed to the bank plus any fees. The home is sold to the highest bidder, unless the state allows the lender to approve the winning bid. In some states, if the house is sold for less than you owe, the lender could go after you for the difference (deficiency judgment). If it is sold for more than what you owe your lender, you get the balance. If the house does not sell, the lender takes over the property.
Benefits Of Selling Before Foreclosure
In most cases, selling your home before foreclosure is a smart financial decision. Here are some benefits of avoiding foreclosure:
- Protects your credit: If you sell before missing multiple payments, you avoid the seven-year blemish on your credit score. You are eligible to buy another home sooner than you would be after a foreclosure.
- Preserves your home equity: If your home value is more than your loan balance, you get to cash out your equity and avoid all the fees, court costs, and late penalties.
- Allows for a short sale: If you owe more than your home is worth, you may be able to go through a short sale or VA compromise sale, and possibly have the balance forgiven.
- You are in control: It gives you control over timing, protects your privacy, and accelerates the process before the bank’s deadline.
Foreclosure vs. Selling Comparison
When facing mortgage distress, deciding whether to proactively sell your home or let it go into foreclosure is one of the most critical financial choices you will make. While both outcomes result in leaving your property, the long-term impact on your credit, personal wealth, and future housing options could not be more different.
Selling puts you in the driver’s seat, allowing you to minimize credit score damage, protect equity, and preserve your option to buy another home down the road. Below is a detailed breakdown comparing how a voluntary sale stacks up against a forced foreclosure across credit impact, home equity, mortgage eligibility, and VA loan entitlement.
Credit Impact
Before comparing long-term wealth, it is essential to evaluate the immediate damage to your credit profile. Missing payments hurts your credit score, but a completed foreclosure creates a severe, multi-year blemish that impacts everything from future loan applications to tenant screening. Comparing how a voluntary sale vs. a forced foreclosure affects your credit score shows how quickly you can expect to recover financially:
|
Selling Your Home |
Foreclosure |
|
|---|---|---|
|
Credit Score Drop |
Late payments only |
Significant score drop |
|
Credit Report |
Late payments may show |
Foreclosure stays for seven years |
|
Recovery Time |
Months |
Multiple years |
Equity
Beyond credit scores, the most direct financial consequence of foreclosure is the complete loss of any equity you have built in your property. While a bank auction focuses solely on satisfying the mortgage debt (often selling the property below market value), a proactive sale allows you to capture remaining home value. The breakdown below highlights how equity, cash at closing, and deficiency risks differ between selling and letting the bank take over:
|
Selling Your Home |
Foreclosure |
|
|---|---|---|
|
Equity Position |
You keep home equity |
You lose all home equity |
|
Deficiency Risk |
None, if the sale covers the balance |
Possible deficiency judgment |
|
Cash at Closing |
Possible proceeds |
None |
Future Homeownership
Losing a home to foreclosure does not mean you can never own property again, but it places strict time barriers on your ability to secure a new mortgage. Lenders, including government-backed programs, impose mandatory waiting periods following a foreclosure before approving new loan applications. The table below outlines how selling early preserves your ability to re-enter the housing market compared to the multi-year delays caused by foreclosure:
|
Selling Your Home |
Foreclosure |
|
|---|---|---|
|
Mortgage Eligibility |
Can buy a home again immediately, if you qualify |
Three to seven-year waiting period depending on loan type |
|
VA Loan Waiting Period |
No waiting period |
Generally, two years after foreclosure |
|
Down Payment |
Depends on loan type (VA/conventional/FHA) |
Generally, a higher down payment is required after foreclosure |
VA Entitlement
For military homeowners and veterans, the decision to sell early or enter foreclosure directly impacts your future government benefit eligibility. A voluntary sale allows you to fully restore your zero-down payment entitlement once the loan is paid off, whereas a foreclosure locks up your entitlement and restricts your ability to secure another VA loan.
|
Selling Your Home |
Foreclosure |
|
|---|---|---|
|
Entitlement Status |
Fully restored after payoff |
Tied up until foreclosure resolved (paid off) |
|
Future VA Loans |
Can use VA entitlement again |
Must wait for restoration |
|
Impact |
Clean exit; entitlement restored |
Entitlement reduced until loan is paid |
Understanding Short Sales and VA Compromise Sales
If you are underwater (meaning you owe more than your home is currently worth) and facing a financial hardship, knowing how the sale of your home impacts your future may help you make the decision to sell or go into foreclosure. Just know that a short or compromise sale can still have a significant impact on your credit. During the waiting period, you can rebuild your credit score by paying down debt and making on-time payments.
If your lender forgives mortgage debt, the IRS can treat the forgiven amount as “cancellation of debt income,” which is taxable in some cases. The Mortgage Forgiveness Debt Relief Act excluded qualified principal residence debt from this action. Because the status of the exclusion has changed multiple times, verify the current rules with a tax professional before closing.
Short Sale
Simply put, a short sale is selling a property for less than what you owe on your mortgage. It is important to know that a short sale is not a guarantee. You must show evidence of a hardship, such as medical bills, divorce, or a permanent change of station (PCS). In the end, your lender must grant you permission to sell your home.
A short sale allows lenders to get back some of the money they lent, while avoiding the time and expense involved in a foreclosure. The short sell also benefits you, because you are relieved of your outstanding debt. While short sales are not always the best option, they are generally better than the alternatives.
Further, you may have to go through a waiting period (generally four years for a conventional loan) before you can apply for another home loan.
VA Compromise Sales
If you have a Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) loan, you may be eligible for a VA compromise sale, which is the VA equivalent of a short sale. In this sale, the VA pays a compromise claim to cover the difference between the outstanding amount you owe on your mortgage and your home’s current market value up to the amount the VA guaranteed for your loan. As in a short sale, your lender must agree to have its loan guaranty reduced by the amount of the claim paid.
VA Compromise Sale Requirements
- You must show financial hardship (divorce, major medical bills, death of a primary wage earner, PCS) and state why you must sell
- The sale must cost the VA less than a foreclosure
- A VA appraisal needed
- The house must be sold at fair market value
- There can be no second liens unless deemed as insignificant
This sale does tie up your VA home loan benefits by the exact cost the VA paid to cover your short sale gap. You do not have to come up with any cash for the sale, but any closing costs may be deducted from the sale proceeds if approved by your lender.
You may have to go through a waiting period (generally two years) before you can apply for another VA-backed loan. It may seem like a long time, but the VA loan waiting period is much less than for a conventional loan.
You only have to pay the VA back if you want to restore your VA loan benefits to full entitlement. That does not mean your entitlements are completely gone. Depending on your situation, you might still have enough of your remaining partial entitlement to buy another home using a VA loan.
When Foreclosure May Be Unavoidable
Even with intervention efforts by your lender or the VA, foreclosure may be unavoidable if you cannot:
- Sell your Home (traditional or short/VA compromise sale)
- Get Relief (mortgage forbearance, loan modification, refinance, VA Partial Claims Program)
- Catch Up (bring your loan current to close to current)
- Negotiate (come up with a viable plan with your lender)
If foreclosure happens, the best course of action is to manage your immediate housing situation, rebuild your credit, and stabilize your finances by building up your savings and sticking to a budget to prevent future debt issues.
Questions to Ask Before Deciding to Sell
Before deciding whether to sell, ask yourself these questions about your equity, delinquency status, ability to catch up, and whether foreclosure paperwork has already been filed.
- Do I have positive equity?
- Will I need to request a short sale?
- What are the full costs to close?
- Where do I stand on my loan timeline?
- Has legal or foreclosure paperwork been filed?
- How fast do I need to close?
- Can I qualify for loss mitigation?
- What is my housing plan after the sale?
Pro Tip: If you are behind on your payments, or are facing the possible in the near future, contact your lender immediately and ask about your options. Let them know if you plan to sell or want to explore loss mitigation options. Lenders prefer a sale over going through the foreclosure process.
Selling vs. Foreclosure Decision Matrix
Which option should you choose; sell your home or go into foreclosure?
1. Do you still have equity?
- YES: Sell your home. In this case, you can pay off your mortgage, avoid the credit hit, and maybe walk away with some cash.
- NO: Go to Step 2
2. Are you more than 90 days behind?
- YES: Foreclosure risk is high. Selling may still be possible, but it depends on timing.
- NO: Selling is still the better option.
3. Can you realistically catch up or get other relief?
- YES: Avoid foreclosure. Consider a loan modification, mortgage forbearance, or refinance.
- NO: Selling may be the best remaining option before foreclosure.
4. Has the lender already filed foreclosure paperwork?
- YES: You may still sell, but the window is extremely narrow. A short or VA compromise sale may be required.
- NO: Selling is still fully viable.
Real-World Foreclosure Scenarios
Scenario 1: Sell Your Home
- Situation: You’re 45 days behind on payments after a job loss. You have $30,000 in equity and the market is strong.
- Best Path: Sell the home. You pay off the mortgage, avoid foreclosure, and walk away with cash to stabilize your finances.
Scenario 2: Sell Your Home (Break Even)
- Situation: You’re 60 days behind. You have just enough equity to cover the mortgage and closing costs.
- Best Path: Sell your home before the lender files foreclosure. You avoid a 7‑year foreclosure credit penalty.
Scenario 3: Short Sale
- Situation: You owe $350,000, but the home is worth $320,000, and you are more than 90 days behind in mortgage payments.
- Best Path: A lender-approved short sale may be appropriate. The lender accepts less than the balance. The credit impact is smaller than foreclosure, and you avoid legal action.
Scenario 4: Foreclosure
- Situation: You’re 6 months behind, the lender has filed for foreclosure, and you have no equity. Also, you cannot sell or qualify for forbearance, modification, or refinancing.
- Best Path: Foreclosure may be the unavoidable outcome. You relocate and work on rebuilding credit.
FAQ
Is selling my home better than foreclosure?
In most cases, yes. Selling avoids the credit hit of foreclosure, prevents the loss of all home equity, and eliminates the risk of deficiency judgments. Even if you’re underwater, a short sale or VA compromise sale is less damaging than foreclosure.
Can I sell my house if I’m behind on payments?
Yes. Being behind on payments does not prevent you from selling. Your missed payments, late fees, and any penalties are paid off at closing. If your home has equity, a traditional sale is possible. If not, a short sale or VA compromise sale may be possible.
Can I sell if I’m behind on payments?
Yes. You can still sell:
- After 30, 60, or 90 days late
- After receiving a Notice of Default
- Even after foreclosure paperwork is filed
Selling is an option until the foreclosure is final.
Does foreclosure permanently hurt my credit?
No. However, the impact is serious and long-lasting. Foreclosure stays on your credit report for seven years and generally causes a large credit score drop. It takes time to recover, future mortgage waiting periods apply, but it is not permanent.
What is a VA compromise sale?
It is basically a short sale for VA-backed loans. If you owe more than your home is worth and can show financial hardship, the VA may cover the difference between your loan balance and the sale price. You avoid foreclosure, but is ties up part of your VA loan entitlement.
Will I lose my VA loan benefit after foreclosure?
No. Foreclosure reduces your full VA entitlement because the VA pays a claim to your lender. You can restore full entitlement only by repaying that loan. Even without full restoration, you may still have enough remaining entitlement to buy another home.
Read the full article here